| 2024 | Delaney Lawson | Bellmont | Utah State |
| | Lauren Evans | Carmel | Butler |
| | Addi Rains | Yorktown | Clemson University |
| | Breonna Goss | HSE | Duke |
| | Tiffany Snook | HSE | University of Memphis |
| | Holli Klettheimer | Frankton | University of Mary |
| | Lola Schumacher | Brebeuf | Wisconsin |
| | Danielle Schade | Westfield | Marian University |
| | Allison Bucur | Burris | Oakland City University |
| | Madelynn Coates | Noblesville | St. Thomas Florida |
| | Macy Hinshaw | Hamilton Southeastern | Santa Clara University |
| | Audrey Hudson | Bishop Dwenger | Wright State University |
| | Ella Mauck | Delta | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Aubrey Stitcher | Noblesville | Austin Peay University |
| | Layla Gonzales | Burris | Southern Indiana University |
| | Lauren Paska | Lapel | Indiana Tech University |
| | Millie Raikes | Eastbrook | Mount Vernon University |
| | Taylor Welch | Westfield | University of Indianapolis |
| | Camaya Murray | Delta | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| 2023 | Emilee Hill | Yorktown | Eastern Kentucky |
| | Sydney Robinson | Brebeuf | Northern Illinois |
| | Naija Gadis | Brebeuf | Jackson State |
| | Kate Shannahan | Deerfield Academy | Santa Clara |
| | Ava Rundle | Noblesville | Indiana State |
| | Reece Baker | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Camryn Wise | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Katherine Barthel | Cathedral | UT Chattanooga |
| | Chloe Cook | Wapahani | Marion |
| | Lily Vester | Yorktown | Bethel |
| | Sarah Molander | Brebeuf | Purdue (Manager) |
| | Samantha Hanson | Cathedral | Juniata |
| | Kate Martin | New Castle | Anderson |
| | Olivia Embry | Wes-Del | IUPU Columbus |
| | Addy Frye | Traders Point | West Point |
| | Delaney Seaman | Brebeuf | Columbia |
| | Ava Harris | Noblesville | IUPUI |
| | Emerson Evans | Carmel | Marion University |
| | Mallory Dills | Cathedral | Washington University |
| | Ava Vickers | Fishers High School | Indiana University |
| | Ramsey Gary | Pendleton High School | Indiana University |
| 2022 | Abigail Kesler | Burris Academy | Lincoln Memorial University |
| | Addy Frye | Traders Point Christian | Liberty University |
| | Meghan Slaninka | Hamilton Southeastern | Colorado School of Mines |
| | Rory Powers | Yorktown High School | Air Force Academy |
| | Ella Bostic | Carmel High School | University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill |
| | Kimora Whetstone | Lawrence North High School | University of Missouri, Kansas City |
| | McKaylah Flagle | Shelbyville | Taylor University |
| | Lovie Wallace | Hamilton Southeastern | University of North Carolina - Greensboro |
| | Kia Knox-Dawkins | Pike High School | Indiana Tech |
| | Emma McMahon | Belmont High School | Eastern Michigan University |
| | Katie Egenolf | Center Grove High School | Ball State University |
| | Sophia Huber | | Calumet College of St. Joseph |
| | Brooke Elliott | Hamilton Southeastern | Liberty University |
| | Lauren Nixon | Burris | University of North Carolina, Charlotte |
| | Eva Hudson | Fort Wayne Bishop Dwenger | Purdue University |
| | Avery Ross | Pendleton High School | University of Notre Dame |
| | Erika Smith | Connersville High School | Wright State University |
| 2021 | Kenzie Daffinee | Westfield High School | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| | Bailey Cox | New Castle High School | University of Georgia |
| | Peighton Isley | Westfield High School | Morehead State University |
| | Camryn Haworth | Fishers High School | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| | Gabby Pelfrey | Fishers | Malone University |
| | Serena Dodson | Lawrence North | Marian University |
| | Logan Smith | Garrett High School | Marion University |
| | Kenzie Hoelscher | Fort Laramie, Ohio | University of Findlay |
| | Jaci Scherb | Carmel High School | University of Mount Union |
| | Alexis Franks | Muncie Central | Indiana University, Southeast |
| | Helen Beach | Burris Academy | Santa Clara University |
| | Carly Mills | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| | Zoe Westlund | Noblesville | Manchester University |
| | Olivia Lux | Fishers High School | Middle Tennessee State University |
| | Ellee Stinson | Yorktown High School | Northwestern University, Chicago |
| | Rose Crist | Noblesville High School | Villanova University |
| | Gracie Conway | Cowan High School | Taylor University |
| | Elly Grenda | Westfield High School | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Skyler Murray | Centerville High School | Earlham College |
| | Jada Allen | Fishers High School | NC State University |
| | Corinne Meier | Burris Academy | Long Island University |
| | Mikayla Christiansen | Fishers High School | North Carolina Central |
| | Bella Dearinger | Delta High School | Murray State University |
| | Jenny Morey | Yorktown High School | Wright State University |
| | Megan Duffy | Tri West High School | Eastern Kentucky University |
| | Jaylynn Dunsmore | Yorktown High School | Taylor University |
| | Lucia Corsaro | Cathedral High School | Xavier University |
| | Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | University of North Carolina - Chapel Hill |
| | Laila Smith | New Castle | Syracuse University |
| | Nicole Wilkinson | New Castle | Rider University |
| 2020 | Lindsey Winner | Versailles High School (Ohio) | University of Dayton |
| | Zoe Conway | New Castle High School | Ball State University |
| | Brittany Baize | Yorktown High School | Grace College |
| | Courtney Watkins | Yorktown High School | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Victoria Bulmahn | Mount Vernon High School | Valparaiso University |
| | Maddi Besser | Yorktown High School | Aurora University |
| | Kate Sperry | Frankton High School | Grace College |
| | Kate Vinson | Yorktown High School | Ball State University |
| | Lauren Gilliland | Coldwater High School | Ball State University |
| | Gracie King | Pendleton Heights High School | University of Indianapolis |
| | Olivia Valentine | Heritage Christian High School | Keiser University |
| | Nevaeh Shugart | Leo High School | Ferris State |
| | Averi Lanman | Pendleton Heights | Marian University, Indianapolis |
| | Lily Sumner | Park Tudor High School | Auburn University |
| | Grace Hunter | Hamilton Southeastern | Marian University, Indianapolis, IN |
| | Emily Brewer | Fishers High School | Grinnell College |
| | Bryneth Roberts | Fishers High School | Kent State University |
| | Maria Zweig | Carmel High School | College of Charleston |
| | Macy Puthoff | New Bremen | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Lillian Leiner | Hamilton Southeastern | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Lorelei Porter | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Indiana University - Kokomo |
| | Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle | University of Minnesota |
| | Anna Johnsey | Westfield High School | Vincennes University |
| | Martina Demarchi | Cowan High School | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Cait Snyder | Angola High School | Ball State University |
| | Kyla Berg | Hamilton Southeastern | Fairfield University |
| | Molly Hunt | Delta High School | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Regan Tinkle | Hagerstown High School | Marshall University |
| | Mara Perry | Burris Indiana Academy | Bellarmine University |
| | Lexie Almodovar | Noblesville | University of Dayton |
| 2019 | Asia Goins | Avon High School | Towson University |
| | Tegan Seyring | Yorktown High School | Austin Peay State University |
| | MyKel Ivy | Burris | Ball State University |
| | Sophie Oliphant | Carmel High School | Indiana University - Bloomington |
| | Bonnie Bostic | Carmel High School | Yale University |
| | Adrianne Vance | Lawrence North High School | Hanover College |
| | Estella Davis | Wapahani | Indiana University - Kokomo |
| | Rachael Ressler | Tipton High School | Manchester University |
| | Addie Sieber | Leo High School | Southern Illinois University Edwardsville |
| | Havyn Gates | Wapahani | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Rachel Woock | Carmel High School | Grinnell College |
| | Taylor Shelton | Hamilton Southeastern | Louisiana Monroe |
| | Kylie Murr | Yorktown | Ohio State/Minnesota |
| | Kinsey McAfee | Westfield High School | Morehead State University |
| | Emily Eppert | Lapel High School | Indiana Tech |
| | Chloe Rains | Oak Hill | University of Northern Ohio |
| | Erin Roach | Wapahani High School | Anderson University |
| | Breanna Small | Beech Grove High School | Trine University |
| | Rose Duffy | Fishers | Western Michigan University |
| | Hannah Crist | Hamilton Heights High School | University of New Hampshire |
| | Alyiah Wells | Briarcrest Christian | University of Alabama |
| | Cassidi Colbert | Homeschool | Grace College |
| 2018 | Arianna Bolinger | Ft. Wayne Caroll | St. Thomas University, Miami, FL |
| | Hallie Holbrook | Shenandoah | Spalding University |
| | Madison Rosenberger | Union County High School | Bethel College, Indiana |
| | Lindsay Ingenito | Daleville | Huntington University |
| | Sammei Fulkerson-Bird | North Central | Indiana University East |
| | Mattie Norris | Cathedral | DePaul University |
| | Brenna Everingham | Noblesville | UT Chattanooga |
| | Claire Hindman | Westfield | Trevecca Nazarene University |
| | Morgan Friend | Ridgeville High School | Trine University |
| | Darian Goins | Avon High School | Louisiana State University |
| | Emily Kleck | Cathedral | New York University |
| | Maddie Hine | Noblesville | University of Iowa |
| | Bailey Green | Delta High School | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Megan Miller | Alexandria | University of Nebraska |
| | Kat Wagner | Hamilton Southeastern | Southern Illinois University Carbondale |
| | Grace Kane | Hamilton Southeastern | Campbell University |
| | Addie Wright | Cathedral | Franklin Pierce University |
| | Ana Collar | Hamilton Heights | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Chelsea Waltermire | Cowan | Manchester University |
| | Madison Candler | Heritage Christian | University of Saint Francis, Ft. Wayne |
| | Mamie Garard | Zionsville | San Jose State University |
| | Cecily Jester | New Castle High School | Southern Illinois University - Carbondale |
| | Chloe' Trissel | Jay County | Indiana University - Kokomo |
| | Mallory Hernandez | Fishers | University of Georgia |
| | Kalyse Garrett | Burris Academy | Tennessee Wesleyan University |
| | Bria King | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Hampton University |
| | Bella Rosenthall | Yorktown | Auburn University |
| | Mallory Green | Union | Indiana Tech |
| | Virginia Wilhoite | Muncie Central High School | Indiana State University |
| | Makayla Knoblauch | Fort Wayne Leo | Quincy University |
| | Jonni Parker | Miami East, OH | Penn State University |
| | Lark Jones | Hamilton Southeastern | Marian University |
| | Lexi Spence | Wapahani | Marian University |
| 2017 | Avarie Powell | New Castle | Miami (Ohio) University |
| | Aubree Lanman | Pendleton Heights | Gannon University |
| | Abby Bowyer | Maconaquah | Indiana University Kokomo |
| | Gabby Zgunda | Delta | Mississippi State University |
| | Katarina DiBiasio | Monroe Central | Saint Francis |
| | Gabby Harrington | Cowan | Grace College |
| | Jenna Scott | Liberty Christian | Bethany College |
| | E'laisah Young | Muncie Central | College of Southern Idaho |
| | Allison Ruddick | Muncie Central | Union College, Kentucky |
| | Chloe Stitt | Delta | Austin Peay |
| | Melody Davidson | Liberty Christian | Butler University |
| | Rhyen Neal | Yorktown | University of Toledo |
| | Natalie Ravenell | Westfield | Butler University |
| | Delaney Sandlin | Eastern | Earlham College |
| | Kinkaid Padgett | Muncie Central | Georgia State |
| | Kanani Price | Madison-Grant | Mississippi State University |
| | Caroline Kirchmer | Hamilton Southeastern | Eastern Illinois |
| | Abby Barcus | Jay County | Wright State University |
| | Kendall Murr | Yorktown | Mississippi State University |
| | Lacee Adams | Muncie Central | Chicago State University |
| | Megan Carr | Zionsville | Ohio State University |
| | Jo Rammel | Muncie Central | Huntington University |
| | Nia Robinson | Cathedral | Northwestern University |
| | Macee Rudy | Shenandoah | IU Kokomo |
| | Taylor Bebout | Bellmont | Western Kentucky |
| | Abigail Huser | Westfield | Miami (Ohio) University |
| | Payton White | Cathedral | Auburn University |
| | Rachel Klitzing | | Indiana Wesleyan University |
| | Kayleigh Wilson | New Castle | Bellarmine University |
| 2016 | April Stiers | Anderson | IU East-Richmond |
| | Courtney Marchello | Greenfield Central | IU Northwest-Gary |
| | Alysa Sutton | Wes-Del | Southern Illinois University - Carbondale |
| | Hannah Smith | Wapahani | Ball State University |
| | Jade York | Yorktown | Butler |
| | Jaqueline Quade | Ft. Wayne Carroll | University of Illinois |
| | Kendall White | Cathedral | Penn State University |
| | Kate Avila | Yorktown | Ball State University |
| | Audrey Adams | Cathedral | Xavier |
| | Anna Jensen | Cathedral | Ball State University |
| | Jazsmyn Townsend | Anderson | Winston-Salem State |
| | Riley Taylor | Perry Meridian | Eastern Michigan |
| | Mimi Arrington | Yorktown | Austin Peay |
| | Elaine Bredensteiner | Westfield | Huntington University |
| | Taylor Smith | Garrett | Maryland |
| | Megan Sloan | Cathedral | University of Louisville |
| | Kaylee Nichols | Delta | DePauw University |
| | Micah Leavell | Muncie Central | Hampton University |
| | Olivia Benner | Tri-West | Mississippi State |
| | Hayden Hubers | Hamilton Southeastern | Indiana University |
| | Nikki Marshall | Muncie Central | University of Saint Francis |
| 2015 | Lucy Grenda | Westfield | Saint Joseph's |
| | Brianna Heffernan | New Castle | University of Indianapolis |
| | Taylor Daniel | Russia Local-Russia, OH | Clemson |
| | Samantha Reed | Westfield | Central Methodist University |
| | Beth Prince | Avon | University of Illinois |
| | Tionna Williams | Ft. Wayne Concordia | University of Wisconsin |
| | Kelly Turner | Fort Laramie | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Tarah Wylie | Cathedral | Pepperdine University |
| | Natalee Walters | Mississnewa | Ancilla College |
| | Hannah Ballard | Northwestern | IUPUI |
| | Carly Skjodt | Carmel | University of Michigan |
| | Caitey Sosnowski | Greenfield Central | St. Mary's College |
| | Lauren Bruns | Versailles | University of Dayton |
| | Quincey Gary | Pendleton Heights | University of Alabama |
| | Kiley Lingenfelter | New Castle | San Jose State University |
| | Sami White | Southwood | Davenport University |
| | Abigail Miller | Alexandria | Auburn University |
| | Delaney O'Neil | Cathedral | Miami (Ohio) University |
| 2014 | Madison Bergren | Delta | UT-Martin |
| | Mary Kilbane | Bishop Chatard | VCU |
| | Sydney Unger | Clinton Cental | Defiance University |
| | Courtney Masters | Wapahani | Elmhurst College |
| | Allie Hueston | Alexandria | Eastern Illinois |
| | Drew Rhamy | Southwood | Regis University |
| | Alexis Brickner | Southwood | IU Kokomo |
| | Annie Phillips | Noblesville | Trine University |
| | Lisa Rodriguez | Union | Goshen College |
| | Jessica Helms | Muncie Central | IUPUI |
| | Jesse Earl | Lawrence North | Auburn University |
| | Lauryn Gillis | New Castle | University of Wisconsin |
| | Natalie Heaton | Wes-Del | IU Kokomo |
| | Katie Elson | Mississinewa | University of Northwestern Ohio |
| | Megan Robbins | Connersville | Manchester |
| | Marissa Elam | Delta | Union College |
| | Savannah Hart | Greenfield Central | Grace College |
| | Laryssa Welch | New Castle | Tusculum |
| | Emily Matio | Hamilton Southeastern | Valdosta State |
| | Olivia Kluger | Cathedral | U.S. Naval Academy |
| 2013 | Katlyn Sawyer | Rochester | Rollins College |
| | Sara Bean | Columbus East | Bellarmine University |
| | Alexis Mapes | Westfield | IUPUI |
| | Nikki Box | Yorktown | Ball State |
| | Sara Hohman | Cathedral | UNC Greensboro |
| | Shelby Foyer | Carmel | University of South Florida |
| | Josie Winner | Marion (Ohio) | Eastern Illinois |
| | Taylor Patterson | New Castle | Tennessee State |
| | Lauren Pitz | Carmel | Georgia Tech |
| | Hunter Wise | Madison Grant | Ball State |
| | Madison Crist | Blackford | Ball State |
| | Jaydn Pegues | Muncie Central | IPFW |
| | Jazzmine McDonald | Cathedral | Indiana University |
| | Brooke Kranda | Westfield | Michigan State University |
| | Ari Anderson | Burris | Tennessee State |
| 2012 | Marah Bradbury | Ft. Wayne Concordia | Eastern Illinois |
| | Emily Wolfert | Yorktown | Hillsdale College |
| | Sierra Reed | Wapahani | Eastern Michigan |
| | Hadley Orr | Clinton Central | Michigan State University |
| | Taylor Morey | Burris | University of Wisconsin |
| | Morgan Bergren | Delta | University of Kentucky |
| | Taylor Richardson | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Jessica Scherb | Carmel | Grace College |
| | Kelsey Barker | Yorktown | Ohio Dominican University |
| | Alix Underwood | Cowan | Grace College |
| | Courtney Harnish | Burris | Indiana University |
| | Katy Vasalakis | Yorktown | Ball State |
| 2011 | Jillian Hopper | Yorktown | Florida Gulf Coast |
| | Whitney Masters | Wapahani | Florida Gulf Coast |
| | Jordan Foyer | Carmel | Kentucky State University |
| | Kierra Jones | Hamilton Southeastern | Purdue University |
| | Katie Muey | Alexandria | East Tennessee State |
| | Alyssa Winner | Marion (Ohio) | Ohio State University |
| | Erica Stahl | Bishop Chatard | University of Cincinnati |
| | Jasmine Childress | Muncie Burris | Florida Southern |
| | Chelsea Bilger | Cathedral | Ohio University |
| | Hannah Clemons | Muncie Burris | Grace College |
| | Sloane White | Brebuf Jesuit | College of Charleston |
| | Alex Fuelling | Bellmont | Ball State |
| | Marquita Marshall | Muncie Central | Ball State |
| | Chelsea Colclasure | Bellmont | Southern Illinois Edwardsville |
| | Chelsea Toth | Muncie Burris | University of Buffalo |
| | Kaycee Acree | Yorktown | Western Michigan |
| | Courtney Roach | New Castle | University of Indianapolis |
| | Jeme Obieme | Brebuf Jesuit | Duke University |
| | Sable Staller | Western | University of Buffalo |
| | Meghan Binkerd | Southwood | University of Indianapolis |
| | Kelly Hopkins | Kokomo | Ball State |
| 2010 | Taylor Unroe | Muncie Burris | University of Florida |
| | Sara Metroka | New Castle | Kennesaw State University |
| | Noelle Eagles | New Castle | Norfolk State |
| | Ashley Pickering | Oak Hill | Taylor University |
| | Lauren Miller | Alexandria | Franklin Pierce University |
| | Ari Eaton | Yorktown | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Elizabeth Barker | Northeastern | Northwood University |
| | Laura Avila | Yorktown | Bowling Green University |
| | Morgan Hahn | Delta | Calvin College |
| | Kaitlin Walton | Delta | Lincoln Memorial University |
| | Sacha Gill | Wes-Del | Grand Valley State |
| | Megan Campbell | Versailles (Ohio) | University of Dayton |
| | Emily MacIntyre | Yorktown | University of Cincinnati |
| | Allyson Morey | Muncie Burris | University of Dayton |
| | Ashley Schmidgall | Centerville | Northwood University |
| | Kathryn Treadway | Cathedral | Northern Kentucky University |
| 2009 | Kristina Kerrigan | Muncie Central | University of Indianapolis |
| | Sam Underwood | Cowan | Tusculum College |
| | Abbey Scroggins | Wes-Del | Western Carolina |
| | Lyndsey Holt | Park Tudor | Samford University |
| | Christiana Gray | Cathedral | Duke University |
| | Kelsey Dixon | Cowan | Olivet Nazarene |
| | Allison Eads | Northfield | Oakland City University |
| | Tessa McGill | Muncie Central | Indiana Purdue Fort Wayne (IPFW) |
| | Mary Ording | Cathedral | University of Wisconsin |
| | Brittany Lee | Cathedral | University of Michigan |
| | Mia Tabberson | Muncie Burris | University of Minnesota |
| | Megan Bell | New Castle | Lincoln Memorial University |
| 2008 | Caitlin Cox | New Castle | Indiana University |
| | April Acree | Yorktown | Indiana University East |
| | Valerie Akerhielm | Carmel | University of Dayton |
| | Brianna Kern | Roncalli | Centenary College |
| | Claire McElheny | Brebeuf Jesuit | University of Michigan |
| | Emily Fisher | Muncie Central | Ball State University |
| | Kayla Lawler | Centerville | Quinnipiac University |
| | Kaylee Smith | Cowan | Slippery Rock University |
| | Kelsie Mauck | Delta | Coastal Carolina |
| | Cassie Marsh | Shenandoah | Alderson-Broaddus |
| | Christie Waters | Muncie Burris | Ball State University |
| 2007 | Meryl Bender | Yorktown | Ohio University |
| | Yvonne Marten | Cathedral | University of Dayton |
| | Kelsey Krzyston | Noblesville | Emory University |
| | Megan Rehmer | Center Grove | North Carolina State |
| | Chelsea Clark | Yorktown | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Morgan Elyea | New Castle | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Kim Kuzma | Muncie Central | University of Wisconsin |
| | Jordan Fullove | Fort Wayne Northrup | Purdue University |
| | Brittany Fallis | Yorktown | Parkland College |
| | Karin Caudill | Muncie Burris | Ball State University |
| | Lauren Rapp | Park Tudor | University of Kentucky |
| | Caitlyn Vann | Muncie Burris | University of Missouri |
| | Kylie Dorton | Delta | University of West Florida |
| | Emily Burke | Cathedral | Pittsburgh |
| | Leslie White | Muncie Burris | Ashford University |
| 2006 | Megan Bower | Cathedral | University of Michigan |
| | Teresa Craig | Muncie Burris | Tennessee Tech |
| | Kamille King | Muncie Central | West Georgia |
| | Lauren Kaminsky | Muncie Burris | Xavier University |
| | Kyleigh Turner | Cowan | University of Indianapolis |
| | Ashley Brown | Roncalli | Jacksonville State |
| | Hannah Fenker | New Castle | East Carolina |
| | Molly Davis | Muncie Burris | Southeast Missouri State |
| | Sarah Rumely | Scecina | University of Kentucky |
| | Krystal Hunter | Richmond | Tennessee State |
| 2005 | Kelli Miller | Muncie Central | Purdue University |
| | Malorie Smith | Delta | Kankakee Community College |
| | Kappy Lang | Muncie Burris | Tennessee Tech |
| | Loren Sloan | Tipton | DePauw University |
| | Kristen Carter | Wapahani | Kankakee Community College |
| | Rachel Alcorn | New Castle | Ball State |
| | Jennifer Shultz | Cowan | Kankakee Community College |
| | Sarah Smith | Muncie Central | Ashland University |
| | McKenzie Mauck | Delta | Ohio University |
| | Hannah Cheeseman | Muncie Burris | DePauw University |
| | Marisa Harmon | Alexandria | Bellarmine University |
| | Ashlee Zeigler | Liberty Christian | Taylor University |
| | Katie Kenline | Norwell | Tennessee Tech |
| | Bethany Akerhielm | Carmel | Dayton |
| | Kristina Johnson | Pike | University of Florida |
| | Ashtyn Humerickhouse | Norwell | Indiana Tech Fort Wayne |
| | Melany Rarey | Blackford | Michigan State University |
| | Alaina Gibson | Muncie Burris | Robert Morris University |
| | Hana Ros | Muncie Burris | Indiana University |
| | Danita Merlau | Cathedral | Purdue University |
| | Kristy Cox | Delta | Indiana State |
| | Ashlee Wright | Cowan University of Maine | University of Maine |
| 2004 | Jen Yoder | Noblesville | Samford University |
| | Kayla Holloway | Madison Grant | Vincennes University |
| | Maren Crabtree | Wapahani | Eastern Illinois |
| | Amanda Cloyd | Yorktown | Virginia Tech |
| | Jocelyn Cook | Maconaquah | Bellarmine University |
| | Heather Fierce | Muncie Central | LSU |
| | Ashley Johnson | Alexandria | High Point University |
| | Christina Dickerson | Muncie Burris | DePauw University |
| | Steph Stearns | New Castle | Huntington University |
| | Veronica Seidle | Wes Del | South Carolina Aikens |
| | Meghan McCormick | Union | Purdue University |
| | Brittany Dixon | Cowan | Mt. Vernon Nazarene |
| 2003 | Blair Buchanan | Delta | University of Albany |
| | Kylee Bauer | Pendleton Heights | New Orleans University |
| | Megan Buck | Pendleton Heights | Morehead State |
| | Kristin Mann | Richmond | IPFW |
| | Amanda McCormick | Muncie Burris | University of Nebraska |
| | Abby Blackburn | New Castle | University of Alabama |
| | Ashley DeNeal | Delta | University of Albany |
| | Samantha Bird | Muncie Central | Ball State |
| | Kimi Freeburg | New Castle | University of Southern California |
| | Kasey Goth | Cowan | UAB |
| | Megan Spurlock | New Castle | University of Evansville |
| | Sona Lee | Muncie Central | University of Evansville |
| 2002 | Jill Miller | Muncie Central | Southeast Missouri State |
| | Megan McGrane | Delta | University of Pittsburgh |
| | Suzi Terrell | New Castle | Jacksonville State |
| | Jennie Burrell | Yorktown | Morehead State |
| | Sarah Obras | Pendleton Heights | Ball State |
| | Lindsay Shondell | Muncie Central | Purdue University |
| | Sarah Lang | Muncie Burris | University of Illinois at Chicago |
| | Abby Borror | New Castle | Western Kentucky |
| | Emily Dye | New Castle | Taylor University |
| | Kisha West | New Castle | Jacksonville State |
| | AJ Nicholas | Muncie Burris | Wake Forest |
| | Jasmine Fullove | Ft. Wayne Snider | University of Tennessee |
| 2001 | Erin Heffner | Ft. Wayne Snider | University of Alabama |
| | Kelli Spisak | Muncie Central | Indiana State |
| | Amber Timmons | Cowan | Northern Kentucky University |
| | Kim McConaha | Centerville | Purdue University |
| | Lori Snider | Wapahani | University of Akron |
| | Cathy Fluegeman | Muncie Burris | American University |
| | Ashley Switzer | Muncie Burris | Vincennes University |
| | Karen Freeburg | New Castle | East Tennessee State |
| | Lisa Griffith | Muncie Central | Wright State |
| | Lynette Moster | Union County | Georgia Tech |
| | Stacie Baldwin | Yorktown | Ball State |
| | Amy Johnson | Eastbrook | Vincennes University |
| | Melissa Elmer | Ft. Wayne Northrop | University of Nebraska |
| | Leigh Marcum | Noblesville | University of Kentucky |
| | Stephanie Keller | Yorktown | Ball State |
| | Liz Wall | Muncie Central | Indiana State |
| 2000 | Meredith Fancher | Muncie Central | Ball State |
| | Katie Mathews | Cathedral | Marian College |
| | Miranda Cook | Maconaquah | University of St. Francis |
| | Ashley Fisher | Muncie Burris | Wake Forest |
| | Carman Malone | Muncie Central | Western Michigan |
| | Cherelle Lampkins | Muncie Burris | Morehead State |
| | Jennifer Richardson | Muncie Central | Indiana State |
| | Whitney Ashcraft | Muncie Burris | University of Virginia |
| | Lacey Ellis | Winchester | Indiana Wesleyan |
| | Nikki Hill | Muncie Central | Indiana University |
| | Jessica Smith | Delta | American International |
| 1999 | Anne Koester | Muncie Burris | University of Kentucky |
| | Cindy Kizer | Muncie Central | Western Michigan |
| | Mandy Gels | St. Henry, Ohio | Wright State |
| | Melissa Wright | Muncie Burris | San Diego State |
| | Andrea Voss | Pendleton Heights | Wright State |
| | Jenna Foster | Muncie Southside | Ball State |
| | Hillary Toivonen | Muncie Burris | Indiana University |
| | Kristi Kuzma | Muncie Central | Eastern Kentucky University |
| | Stephanie Ballard | Muncie Burris | College of Charleston |
| | Jacqui Gerlach | St. Henry, Ohio | Duquesne University |
| 1998 | Erica Meyers | Muncie Burris | Taylor University |
| | Jackie Poe | New Castle | IPFW |
| | Deanna Brown | Blue River | IPFW |
| | Ann MacMillan | Muncie Burris | University of New Orleans |
| | Jill Lucas | Wes Del | Tusculum College |
| | Stephanie Bishop | Ft. Wayne Northrop l | DePaul University |
| | Julie Zylka | Delta | Ball State |
| | Jen Miller | New Castle | IPFW |
| 1997 | Amanda Wingertsahn | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Christi Kelsey | Delta | Purdue University |
| | Staci Shipley | Muncie Central | Indiana State |
| | Natalie Marquell | Delta | University of Texas at El Paso |
| | Emily Sallee | Muncie Burris | Ball State |
| | Christy Girton | Muncie Central | Notre Dame |
| | Morgan Wallen | Wes-Del | University of Houston |
| | Kylie Galbraith | Anderson Highland | Butler University |
| 1996 | Sara Sorrell | Muncie Central | University of Illinois |
| | Keylee Wright | Muncie Burris | University of Wisconsin |
| | Debbie Barr | Muncie Central | University of Southern Illinois |
| | Holly Hartley | Muncie Central | IPFW |
| | Laura Lawson | Anderson Highland | IPFW |
| | Nicole Key | Yorktown | Purdue University |
| | Karen Brown | Delta | IPFW |
| | Kambi Meyer | Muncie Burris | Morehead State |
| | Anna Howard | Muncie Burris | Wheaton College |
| 1995 | Lindsay Follin | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Melissa O'Neal | Wapahani | University of Kentucky |
| | Renee Williams | Delta | Oakland University |
| | Lindsay Fisher | Delta | Southern Illinois University |
| | Chandra Hopkins | Warsaw | University of Missouri |
| | Carrie Childs | Muncie Burris | Ohio University |
| | Melissa Forcum | Blackford | Harvard University |
| | Sara Bright | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Lori Moehring | Anderson Highland | Miami (Ohio) University |
| | Marissa Mackey | Muncie Burris | University of Wisconsin |
| | Stephanie McShurley | Muncie Burris | Butler University |
| 1994 | Erica Dewald | Macanaquah | Western Kentucky University |
| | Sarina Harris | Wapahani | Purdue University |
| | Liz Cothren | Cowan | Ball State |
| | Cami Sheffield | Muncie Burris | Western Carolina |
| | Anne Wissel | Richmond | Ball State |
| | Wendy Watkins | Delta | Bowling Green University |
| | Heidi Coulter | Delta | University of Illinois |
| | Jessica Stout | Hagerstown | Miami (Ohio) University |
| | Krystal Jamerson | Muncie Burris | Wright State |
| | Angie Chappel | Anderson Highland | Anderson University |
| | Angie Harris | Ft. Wayne Northrop | Notre Dame |
| | Caroline Clock | Muncie Burris | University of Arkansas |
| | Rachel Cool | Muncie Central | University of Tampa |
| | Gretchen Breitenfield | Delta | Indiana State |
| 1993 | Ginger Jordan | Wapahani | University of Cincinnati |
| | Angie Kammer | Muncie Burris | Penn State University |
| | Linsie Peacock | Blackford | Butler University |
| | Clarisse Chimbanda | Muncie Central | Cleveland State |
| | Sacha Caldemeyer | Muncie Burris | University of Pacific |
| | Rachel Habansky | Muncie Burris | Miami (Ohio) University |
| | Allison Lind | Anderson Highland | Manhattan College |
| | Kim Krull | Bellmont | UCLA |
| | Tammy Juergens | Delta | University of Texas |
| | Syreeta Guinn | Yorktown | Oakland University |
| | Melissa Miller | Anderson Highland | University of Cincinnati |
| | Brooke Orrick | Muncie Central | Rice University |
| | Krista Rhoades | Pendelton Heights | Tri-State |
| 1992 | Ruth Long | Delta | Vincennes University |
| | Amy Baldwin | Yorktown | Wabash Valley College |
| | Chanda Stebbins | Delta | University of Florida |
| | Stacie Murr | Anderson Highland | Indiana University |
| | Michelle Martin | Wapahani | Indiana State |
| | Tiffany Stevens | Yorktown | Ball State |
| | Kerry Hayden | Delta | Tri-State |
| | Hilary Love | Muncie Burris | Virginia Tech |
| | Kelly Harris | Ft. Wayne Snider | Arizona State University |
| | Debbie Peresie | Muncie Central | Indiana State |
| | Angie Breitenfield | Muncie Burris | University of Texas |
| 1991 | Kerri Huffman | Wapahani | Indiana State |
| | Becky Burke | Daleville | Wabash Valley College |
| | Jill Turner | Muncie Southside | Tennessee Tech |
| | Jennifer Cook | Muncie Central | Western Kentucky University |
| | Renee Galore | Muncie Burris | Purdue University |
| | Molly Mooney | Muncie Burris | University of Tennessee |
| | Denise Decaroli | Muncie Burris | Hanover College |
| 1990 | Angie Meyer | Muncie Burris | University of Wisconsin |
| | Alisha Mitro | Muncie Burris | Purdue University |
| | Amy Jones | Delta | University of Illinois |
| | Amy Collinsworth | Ft. Wayne Snider | University of South Carolina |
| | Jill Amman | Muncie Burris | DePauw University |
| | Teresa Jones | Daleville | Ohio University |
| | Angie Scott | Anderson Highland | Ball State |
| | Robin King | Pendleton Heights | East Tennessee State |
| | Jamille Taylor | Muncie Southside | Indiana University |
| 1989 | Carey Amos | Muncie Burris | Bowling Green University |
| | Kim Kumfer | Ft. Wayne Snider | Penn State University |
| | Traci King | New Castle | University of Evansville |
| | Joani Kirby | Daleville | Wright State |
| | Sharlee Stoner | Oak Hill | University of Evansville |
| | Monica Ramey | Anderson Highland | IUPUI |
| | Dana Olden | Muncie Southside | Southern Illinois University |
| | Stefanie Decker | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Tammy Swords | Anderson Highland | Southwestern Michigan College |
| | Sheri Stout | Muncie Burris | University of Indiana |
| | Shawn Butler | Muncie Burris | Colorado College |
| | Barb Pugsley | Daleville | University of Indianapolis |
| | Michelle Ferrell | Daleville | Ball State |
| | Amy Morgan | Muncie Southside | Bowling Green University |
| | Colleen Schug | Pendleton Heights | University of Louisville |
| 1988 | Tracy Hackleman | Delta | Indiana State |
| | Lisa Rolf | Muncie Burris | Illinois State |
| | Tammy Compton | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Holly Cravens | Muncie Burris | Kankakee City College |
| | Stacey Barron | Anderson Highland | IUPUI |
| | Anita Jo Lea | Jay County | Ball State |
| | Erin Jones | Daleville | IPFW |
| | Julie Wilson | Anderson Highland | Southwestern Michigan College |
| 1987 | Laura Linder | Muncie Burris | University of Kentucky |
| | Amber Douglas | Pendleton Heights | Purdue University |
| | Pam Brown | Pendleton Heights | IUPUI |
| | Julie Robinson | Muncie Central | Xavier University |
| | Tiffani Kaeser | Muncie Burris | IUPUI |
| | Sara Wilson | Shenandoah | University of Wisconsin |
| | Trecia Holloway | Pendleton Heights | University of Mississippi |
| 1986 | Wendy Jones | Muncie Burris | University of Tennessee |
| | Angela Rolf | Muncie Burris | Illinois State |
| | Lisa McAtee | New Castle | Illinois State |
| | Mary Beth Singleton | Muncie Burris | Ball State |
| | Tracy Hall | Daleville | University of Evansville |
| 1985 | Lynne Fullhart | Muncie Burris | Florida State |
| | Colleen McKenzie | Cowan | University of South Carolina |
| | Jill Burris | Muncie North | Ball State |
| | Jodi Johnson | Muncie Burris | IPFW |
| | Susan Weed | Pendleton Heights | Butler University |
| | Angie Garner | Pendleton Heights | Illinois State |
| | Amy Garrett | Yorktown | Illinois State University |
| 1984 | Patty Dunham | Muncie Burris | Indiana University |
| | Sherri Rinker | Pendleton Heights | Ohio State University |
| | Kim Osterhoff | Muncie Burris | Louisiana State University |
| | Dawn Davenport | Eastbrook | University of Texas |
| | Julie Cauley | Pendleton Heights | Indiana University |
| | Paula Lloyd | Ben Davis | Ball State |
| | Kim Britt | Ben Davis | Florida State |
| | Karen Dunham | Muncie Burris | Indiana University |
| | Terri Rinker | Pendleton Heights | Ohio State University |
| | Sherrie Waters | Cowan | IPFW |
| | Laura Cramer | Muncie Burris | Bowling Green University |
| | Carrie Stewart | Ben Davis | IUPUI |
| | Julie Wittig | Muncie Burris | Northwestern University |
| | Trista Kibby | Muncie Burris | University of Pennsylvania |
| 1983 | Leesa Gross | Bellmont | Kansas State |
| | Mary Jo Keefer | Muncie Burris | St. Joseph's College |
| | Anne Flynn | Muncie North | Murray State |
| | Julie Neal | New Castle | Indiana University |
| | Janelle Johnson | Muncie Burris | Ball State |
| | Debbie Leaman | | Purdue University |
| | Beverly Craig | | Ball State |
| | Sherrie Clevenger | Wes-Del | St. Josephs College |
| | Kammy Hires | | St. Joseph's College |
| 1982 | Stacy Jordan | Wapahani | Ball State |
| | Nancy Rowland | Muncie North | Indiana University |
| | Linda Bousman | New Castle | Vincennes University |
| | Penny Howard | New Castle | Kent State |
| 1980 | Michelle Burton | Muncie Burris | Western Michigan University |
| 1979 | Linda Bunton | New Castle | University of Kentucky |
| | Liz Douglas | Muncie Burris | Northwestern University |
| | Julie Mullin | | Purdue University |
| 1978 | Cindy Dewitt | Muncie North | Indiana University |
| | Debbie McClurg | Wes-Del | Indiana University |
| 1977 | Wendy Johnson | | Ball State |
| 1976 | Christy Wagner | Muncie North | Michigan State University |
| | Debbie Dick | | Pepperdine University |
| | Debbie Dewitt | Muncie North | Indiana University |
| | Laura Kiefer | Muncie Burris | Ball State |
| | Cindy Parker Nestel | Muncie North | Indiana University |
| | Karen McClurg | Wes-Del | Ball State |
| | Dana McVicker | | Ball State |
| | Liz Albright | Muncie North | Indiana University |
| 1975 | Joannie Smith | Muncie North | Arizona State University |
| | Sandy Schneider | Muncie North | Valparaiso University |
| | Peri Hankins | Muncie North | Ball State |